August 12, 2019
Flathub, brought to you by…
Over the past 2 years Flathub has evolved from a wild idea at a hackfest to a community of app developers and publishers making over 600 apps available to end-users on dozens of Linux-based OSes. We couldn’t have gotten anything off the ground without the support of the 20 or so generous souls who backed our initial fundraising, and to make the service a reality since then we’ve relied on on the contributions of dozens of individuals and organisations such as Codethink, Endless, GNOME, KDE and Red Hat. But for our day to day operations, we depend on the continuous support and generosity of a few companies who provide the services and resources that Flathub uses 24/7 to build and deliver all of these apps. This post is about saying thank you to those companies!
Running the infrastructure
Mythic Beasts is a UK-based “no-nonsense” hosting provider who provide managed and un-managed co-location, dedicated servers, VPS and shared hosting. They are also conveniently based in Cambridge where I live, and very nice people to have a coffee or beer with, particularly if you enjoy talking about IPv6 and how many web services you can run on a rack full of Raspberry Pis. The “heart” of Flathub is a physical machine donated by them which originally ran everything in separate VMs – buildbot, frontend, repo master – and they have subsequently increased their donation with several VMs hosted elsewhere within their network. We also benefit from huge amounts of free bandwidth, backup/storage, monitoring, management and their expertise and advice at scaling up the service.
Starting with everything running on one box in 2017 we quickly ran into scaling bottlenecks as traffic started to pick up. With Mythic’s advice and a healthy donation of 100s of GB / month more of bandwidth, we set up two caching frontend servers running in virtual machines in two different London data centres to cache the commonly-accessed objects, shift the load away from the master server, and take advantage of the physical redundancy offered by the Mythic network.
As load increased and we brought a CDN online to bring the content closer to the user, we also moved the Buildbot (and it’s associated Postgres database) to a VM hosted at Mythic in order to offload as much IO bandwidth from the repo server, to keep up sustained HTTP throughput during update operations. This helped significantly but we are in discussions with them about a yet larger box with a mixture of disks and SSDs to handle the concurrent read and write load that we need.
Even after all of these changes, we keep the repo master on one, big, physical machine with directly attached storage because repo update and delta computations are hugely IO intensive operations, and our OSTree repos contain over 9 million inodes which get accessed randomly during this process. We also have a physical HSM (a YubiKey) which stores the GPG repo signing key for Flathub, and it’s really hard to plug a USB key into a cloud instance, and know where it is and that it’s physically secure.
Building the apps
Our first build workers were under Alex’s desk, in Christian’s garage, and a VM donated by Scaleway for our first year. We still have several ARM workers donated by Codethink, but at the start of 2018 it became pretty clear within a few months that we were not going to keep up with the growing pace of builds without some more serious iron behind the Buildbot. We also wanted to be able to offer PR and test builds, beta builds, etc — all of which multiplies the workload significantly.
Thanks to an introduction by the most excellent Jorge Castro and the approval and support of the Linux Foundation’s CNCF Infrastructure Lab, we were able to get access to an “all expenses paid” account at Packet. Packet is a “bare metal” cloud provider — like AWS except you get entire boxes and dedicated switch ports etc to yourself – at a handful of main datacenters around the world with a full range of server, storage and networking equipment, and a larger number of edge facilities for distribution/processing closer to the users. They have an API and a magical provisioning system which means that at the click of a button or one method call you can bring up all manner of machines, configure networking and storage, etc. Packet is clearly a service built by engineers for engineers – they are smart, easy to get hold of on e-mail and chat, share their roadmap publicly and set priorities based on user feedback.
We currently have 4 Huge Boxes (2 Intel, 2 ARM) from Packet which do the majority of the heavy lifting when it comes to building everything that is uploaded, and also use a few other machines there for auxiliary tasks such as caching source downloads and receiving our streamed logs from the CDN. We also used their flexibility to temporarily set up a whole separate test infrastructure (a repo, buildbot, worker and frontend on one box) while we were prototyping recent changes to the Buildbot.
A special thanks to Ed Vielmetti at Packet who has patiently supported our requests for lots of 32-bit compatible ARM machines, and for his support of other Linux desktop projects such as GNOME and the Freedesktop SDK who also benefit hugely from Packet’s resources for build and CI.
Delivering the data
Even with two redundant / load-balancing front end servers and huge amounts of bandwidth, OSTree repos have so many files that if those servers are too far away from the end users, the latency and round trips cause a serious problem with throughput. In the end you can’t distribute something like Flathub from a single physical location – you need to get closer to the users. Fortunately the OSTree repo format is very efficient to distribute via a CDN, as almost all files in the repository are immutable.
After a very speedy response to a plea for help on Twitter, Fastly – one of the world’s leading CDNs – generously agreed to donate free use of their CDN service to support Flathub. All traffic to the dl.flathub.org domain is served through the CDN, and automatically gets cached at dozens of points of presence around the world. Their service is frankly really really cool – the configuration and stats are reallly powerful, unlike any other CDN service I’ve used. Our configuration allows us to collect custom logs which we use to generate our Flathub stats, and to define edge logic in Varnish’s VCL which we use to allow larger files to stream to the end user while they are still being downloaded by the edge node, improving throughput. We also use their API to purge the summary file from their caches worldwide each time the repository updates, so that it can stay cached for longer between updates.
To get some feelings for how well this works, here are some statistics: The Flathub main repo is 929 GB, of which 73 GB are static deltas and 1.9 GB of screenshots. It contains 7280 refs for 640 apps (plus runtimes and extensions) over 4 architectures. Fastly is serving the dl.flathub.org domain fully cached, with a cache hit rate of ~98.7%. Averaging 9.8 million hits and 464 Gb downloaded per hour, Flathub uses between 1-2 Gbps sustained bandwidth depending on the time of day. Here are some nice graphs produced by the Fastly management UI (the numbers are per-hour over the last month):
To buy the scale of services and support that Flathub receives from our commercial sponsors would cost tens if not hundreds of thousands of dollars a month. Flathub could not exist without Mythic Beasts, Packet and Fastly‘s support of the free and open source Linux desktop. Thank you!
6 responses to “Flathub, brought to you by…”
Leave a Reply to MayeulC Cancel reply
- March 2023
- November 2022
- May 2022
- February 2022
- June 2021
- January 2021
- August 2019
- October 2018
- July 2017
- May 2010
- October 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- March 2009
- January 2009
- July 2008
- June 2008
- April 2008
- May 2007
- January 2007
- December 2006
- June 2006
- April 2006
- March 2006
- November 2005
- October 2005
- September 2005
- August 2005
- July 2005
- May 2005
- April 2005
- March 2005
Relying on goodwill does not seem sustainable or wise. I’d also like to see your calculations for the estimate of cost on typical cloud providers. You also fail to mention how much this would cost if not gifted.
Well, it’s certainly not unconditional goodwill, the companies sponsoring are doing this for the marketing, recruitment, etc benefits they get from supporting open source projects and being seen to do so. It’s hardly unprecedented for FOSS projects to be sustained in small or large part by the activities of corporate entities who also get something from the equation. It’s sustainable enough, given it’s how many of the FOSS projects we rely on continue to exist.
Given the multiple CDNs who replied to my (hardly high-visibility) Tweet offering support (and can be seen to be actively support other FOSS projects), and my knowledge of other entities like Freedesktop and GNOME who receive donated compute time or physical hosting, I’m not unduly worried that if needs be we couldn’t find alternative donors or, with adjustments (and potential degradation) to the service, cover the costs through donations.
In terms of costs I don’t always receive valid invoices for everything but doing a quick estimate looks like Fastly (admittedly not the cheapest CDN) would be above 40,000 USD per month, around 5,000 USD for Packet, and 500 USD for Mythic Beasts. So to pay for everything right now, $46k/month, but I think cheaper could be found if we were trying to optimise for cost.
Is Fastly serving all the traffic to you website and hosting the entire site or just certain static images etc (that represents the most mundane CDN uses cases)?
It’s hosting the software repository itself, that’s why we have 100s of GB of data which Fastly is caching for us. They are content-addressed – ie, ostree names the files after the hash of their contents – so we’re able to set really long Expiry times on most of the files inside the repo (see our nginx configuration on the repo master) and it caches really well. The notable exceptions are the summary file (and it’s detached signature) which are updated every time software in the repo is added or modified. We used to not cache these but it was generating 10s of Mbits/s load on our repo master, so we instead changed to cache them for a few hours, and have the repo manager software explicitly purge them from the CDN and frontend servers after an update. That works way better!
Hum, this got me thinking… Couldn’t part of the data be served trough bittorrent, optionally seeding? This would allow to offset some of the bandwidth costs, the opt-in reduces the privacy issues, and could allow setting up a very fast mirroring system on a local network, without much hassle.
The only downside is that I use flatpaks on my desktop, but not on my server, which would reduce a bit the usefulness of such a system.
I don’t think ostree is a good match for Bittorrent (lots and lots of small files, the exact ones you need not easy to predict ahead of starting the download) but there is certainly scope for a mechanism to be contributed to ostree and make this kind of P2P fetching possible. I’ve always been intrigued by combining ostree (content addressed) with a content addressed network technology such as IPFS. There each object can be fetched from a global P2P network by its hash, and anyone (LAN, worldwide, etc) that has the file can help to meet your request. Endless worked on LAN and USB sharing of ostree/Flatpak installs and updates so all of the fundamental concepts are there to have the publishing (trusted) separated from the fetching (across multiple transports, potentially untrusted).